5 Easy Ways to Tell if Your Social Media Expert is a Fake

by Kathi Kruse

“The mimicry of passion is the most intolerable of all poses.” ~Oscar Wilde

There are a lot of Social Media poseurs out there.

I can’t tell you how many times a week I see great dealers paying good money for Social Media sewage. My years of running dealerships compels me to speak up because I was once sitting in the same chair making these business decisions. I’ve never been one to keep my mouth shut when I see opportunism and exploitation and you can bet I’m not stopping now. These carpetbaggers ride into the store, looking and sounding like they’re the answer to all your burning desires with Social Media. They make it sound great: just pay me $___ every month and we’ll have you gaining fans immediately. Don’t fall for it. They harm your brand and they are harming our industry.

You can’t automate Social Media.

Your store is unique, like a fingerprint. Your employees are unique. Your customers and surrounding community is unique. The content you provide your community needs to be that unique. That’s not possible to automate. Successful Social Media can only be achieved with time, effort and creativity. I have actually seen identical content from many stores on Facebook. Why? Because they have the same “Social Media Provider”. Simply put: if you want eyeballs (and fans/followers) you better be sharing something that no one else has and it better be awesome.

You can’t throw money at it.

Contrary to years ago where you could advertise and people would walk in the door, Social Media is an investment in sales relationships. Let’s face it: we have to market where the customer is and they are on Social Media. This new way of marketing depends on an internal operations process including someone to manage the marketing, blogging, listening, conversing, and recognizing opportunities when they arise. Spending a monthly fee for “management” is better spent on in-house growth. No one communicates your brand like you. Grow your own. It makes all the difference.

What’s their Klout score?

Klout.com is a Social influence measurement tool. Klout measures the level of online interaction and influence a person has on the topics they cover. You can search using their Twitter handle. The next time you meet a Social Media provider, ask them their Klout score. If it’s not north of 50, run. Some providers don’t even know what Klout is.

Have they submitted a marketing plan to you?

Social Media platforms are cheap and easy to set up. They’re designed that way. Facebook, Twitter, YouTube–they all provide you with a free piece of real estate. It’s your job to make that property interesting for your fans/followers and that’s what costs money. You need skill and experience to communicate what’s great about your store while delivering relevant content that engages your audience. With the new Timeline for Pages, Facebook advertising plays a major roll in dealership marketing campaigns. Facebook ads require twice-daily monitoring and tweaking. Does your Social Media expert know that? Who’s going to run your Social ad campaigns?

Each platform requires a different content strategy.

There are many cool strategies on Facebook that don’t work on Twitter, and vice verse. Blogging has it’s own strategy and posts can be shared on different platforms. Video posts lend themselves better than written posts in certain circumstances. Does your provider know which is best? What should you blog about? How will you know if you’re getting results? You’ll know when your analytics say so, when your community starts interacting with you and, of course, when you generate leads.

Many dealers say, “Oh, you can’t sell cars on Social Media”. They discount its value because it’s new and strange. People said the same thing about the telephone, the internal combustion engine and light beer. They see others fail and with good reason: their providers are doing the absolute bare minimum. There is a very defined marketing strategy to Social Media and even though the tactics change often, you CAN generate leads. The caveat is you have to do it right! The bottom line is that if you’re spending your budget on Social Media management, you should be getting results. It’s high noon, do you know where your Social Media is?

 

  • http://www.commencia.com Mike Hale

    Great post, but I have to disagree with you about the Klout score advice. (And not just because mine it below your 50 point mark).

    Just as you can’t automate social media, you can’t create an algorithm to determine somone’s level of influence. Klout is a great tool for measuring reach, but I know quite a few (actual) social media experts with lower Klout scores, and some that have even removed their profiles entirely.

  • http://www.krusecontrolinc.com Kathi Kruse

    Hi Mike, Klout is a hot topic and I also know many who have deleted their profile and let their work stand on it’s own. In my industry (automotive retail), clients need information to make the best decision and Klout scores are one component in the overall assessment of providers. A Klout score are valuable in this specific case…so is a Kred score (I just thought I’d stick with one concept to keep it simple). Thanks for your comment!

  • http://www.go-blog-go.com Mallie Dein

    Agree with Mike on Klout. Deleted my profile and won’t create a new one. Case studies and client referrals should be able to stand in here.

    Everything else you wrote is absolute gold. I’ve long been anti-automation, and it’s nice to see someone eloquently state why it isn’t the best option.

    Have a great week!

  • http://www.buzzedup.co.uk Mick Dickinson (@MickDickinson)

    Good post. I’d like to put some perspective on point 1. Yes, of course you can’t automate all social media. But you can semi-automate some. If I have say 500 pieces of valuable content to share, and that content is ‘timeless’ (if you know what I mean), then I sure as hell am going to schedule some of that content using the (pretty smart) technology that is available to me. It means I can spend more quality time on the realtime responses, conversations and reactions.

  • http://www.krusecontrolinc.com Kathi Kruse

    Hi Mick, I agree with you on using tools to schedule posts. That’s still curated content that is valuable to the audience. The automation I’m referring to is content that isn’t specific, that gets posted on a multitude of unsuspecting clients’ Facebook pages (often at the same time!) and doesn’t communicate the uniqueness of each clients’ brand. Thanks so much for your comment!

  • http://janetcallaway.com Janet Callaway

    Kathi, aloha. Love the term “social media sewage.” That definitely says it.

    Your points make perfect sense to me. Even though I deleted my 70+ Klout score, if I were in the business of advising companies on social media, I might well have kept it as well as Kred. That being said, I think the best “proof” is when they can see what you have done for others.

    Thoroughly enjoyed reading your thought process.

    Best wishes for a terrific week ahead. Until next time, aloha. Janet

  • http://www.four51.com JennyKayPollock

    Great advise. It is defiantly important to have someone who knows what they are doing managing and implementing your social media plan.

    “Simply put: if you want eyeballs (and fans/followers) you better be sharing something that no one else has and it better be awesome.” – Great point. So many people wonder why they are not seeing the results they want and it is because they are not following this!

  • http://www.clickclickmedia.com.au Daniel

    I agree with everything minus Klout score. Completely irrelevant. Track record and testimonials.

  • Christopher Epps

    Kathi-
    I really enjoyed your article. Period!
    Keep putting out good stuff like this and I can promise you I’ll be a raving fan!
    Thanks for sharing!

  • http://www.krusecontrolinc.com Kathi Kruse

    Thanks Christopher!

  • Doug Caywood

    Great insights Kathi. Thanks!
    Maybe the best use of Klout score is as an indicator for self-improvement. A reminder of other platforms and methods.
    Involvement builds volume and personal involvement may, as you’ve indicated, build greater trust and brand authority …http://bit.ly/wHcMsO

  • http://www.krusecontrolinc.com Kathi Kruse

    I agree Doug. While Klout is not very transparent, there are still ways to measure yourself if you’re a Social Media user because you inherently understand what drives RT’s, shares, likes etc (ie: content). Kred.ly is a great site too. Thanks for commenting!

  • http://www.AtkinsMarketingSolutions.com Stuart Atkins

    Looks like Klout has none. Great post. The key to any good plan includes solid objectives to guide and direct the plan. Social media success does not necessarily require an expert to drive sales, customer engagement, and brand awareness. Same rules; new tools. And, if that “expert” does not advocate a website as the foundation any social media strategy, well, run and don’t look back. As effective as social media is, we don’t own our social media pages or accounts. Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn does. We do own our websites. All social media roads should lead back to a website. Thanks again!

  • http://www.elirose.com liz

    Like many of the commenters above, I am not a fan of Klout. Deleted my account back in October though Klout STILL has not removed it. But that’s a different conversation for a different time. ;-)

    Also, in spending time doing social for others, I don’t have time to put gobs of effort into social myself. So if I were to have an active Klout presence, my score would not be reflective of the time I spend engaging on social since the bulk of that time is being active for accounts other than my own.

    I totally agree about not automating (at least not Facebook). The only thing I ever automate: a few new blog post tweets to go out a few times over the course of the day. But otherwise, it’s me actually interacting the rest of the time.

    And I also totally agree that each platform needs to be treated independently.

  • http://www.copybreak.com.au Anna @ Copybreak

    Klout has me baffled. I’ve been in social media circles for over 2 years and have built a solid Facebook & Twitter following, have Google+, LinkedIn and Klout profiles, as well as blog which receives plenty of comments. I have a score (currently) of 42.

    A mate of mine started a Twitter account a couple of months ago, has less followers than he is following and no other social media accounts at all. His current score is 37.

    Then other people I follow on social media who blog, have loads of followers and are very actively engaged only rank from 10-29! What the..?

    It seems to me these scores are somewhat arbitrary and I find it hard to place any faith in them whatsoever.

    But Klout aside, I can’t argue with any of your other points. Great stuff.

  • http://www.krusecontrolinc.com Kathi Kruse

    Thanks for your comment, Anna! It’s amazing to me that my Klout point has met such resistance. In my industry, it’s used as simply an indicator among many. Car dealers are at a disadvantage when vetting Social Media “providers” and Klout delivers some peace of mind. I see your point and agree that it’s hard to see why some scores are high when others are lower. Some of the “providers” of automotive Social Media have NO score or are in the teens and that indicates that they are not in the social space with any kind of regularity. I believe you cannot develop winning content strategy if you are not familiar with it nor understand it as a user.

  • Carolyn B.

    Great article, Kathi! I agree with the comments about Klout simply because it is still new, and I know I question its reliability similar to Anna’s point above. I think one thing I might add to your list is being ahead of the curve and staying up to date with SM news, changes and research. Nothing is worse to me than a client or coworker who doesn’t work in SM to ask ‘Hey, have you heard about the changes to…’ That’s why I make it a point to not only educate myself every day in this fast-paced industry, but also keep my clients and coworkers informed with the hard and fast ‘what these changes mean for you.’ It’s important to tailor the influx of news and condense the key nuggets. After all, it’s in your best interest to show clients that you are the ‘expert’ and not a ‘poseur.’ Great piece!

  • http://www.krusecontrolinc.com Kathi Kruse

    Thanks Carolyn. Great point about staying up to date with everything. Whenever I am tired and not feeling like curating content for my audience, I remember how much information I derive from that process and it perks me up. I agree, it’s so important to help clients with “what these changes mean for you”. They look to us to suss out all the noise and give them the straight scoop. Thanks for reading my piece and your insight!

  • Amy Lang

    Kathi – I agree with your post, but have reservations too about the Klout score. And I’m pleased to see you chose to lead with the point on automation. There’s plenty of folks out there who believe they can set up content a month in advance and push it out. Hello .. relevancy? Timeliness? On-hands engagement is the only way to build conversations and relationships. Thanks for a great article!

  • http://www.krusecontrolinc.com Kathi Kruse

    Thanks for your feedback, Amy! You’re so right about “month-in-advance” content…hellooo, nobody reads that! Everyone wants to use their time efficiently. Hands-on engagement is efficient! Like you said, it fosters conversations and builds relationships. If your brand supports it, creating an editorial calendar works well. But all that can go out the window if something huge is happening that’s relevant to the audience. If nobody is monitoring engagement, then you miss those chances.

  • http://SeymourResults.com Cynthia K Seymour

    Gosh… I am so glad you wrote this post! I consulted with a company yesterday who said that they have a Social Media manager. When I investigated their online presence, all the manager does is post one Facebook status update and then pipe it to Twitter. The worst is when the tweets are just spammy automated corporate messaging. The sad thing is… these are the social media “gurus” who least understand the media and their cheesy tactics make a bad name for us all. Business owners need to be clear that Social Media is an organic and one-by-one building of relationships. (I am even considering attaching a copy of the fairy tale “The Emperor’s New Clothes” to every online presence audit that I conduct)

  • http://www.krusecontrolinc.com Kathi Kruse

    Thanks Cynthia! I’m so glad my info was timed right and helpful :-)

  • http://www.amanda-hill.org.uk Amanda Hill

    Love this piece.. but do agree on the klout thing.. personally I believe it is a measure of noise.. and I do have a score north of 50… I have been using social media before it became trendy and rebranded and find it very funny that there are so many people saying they are gurus with a year old twitter account (although hands up I deleted my first one…) Thanks..

  • Pingback: Actually, Klout is a great tool for hiring digital natives | VentureBeat

  • Pingback: Why you should be using Klout when making hiring decisions | Tin Surf24h

  • Pingback: Why you should be using Klout when making hiring decisions | Share Blog

  • Pingback: Actually, Klout is a great tool for hiring digital natives | MyTouch 4G Review

  • Pingback: Should Klout Drive Hiring Decisions? | Needle.

Previous post:

Next post: