You’re Doing It Wrong! Why Your Facebook Ads Aren’t Working

by Kathi Kruse

facebook ads automotive social mediaEverybody loves to hate Facebook.

You may or may not have caught some of the talk surrounding GM’s Facebook Ads decampment.  GM does not understand Facebook marketing.  There, I said it.  To that point, this post from AdAge’s B.L. Ochman on 11 boring things GM posted on Facebook says it all.  GM’s Facebook marketing is a shining example of a company that wants to broadcast instead of listen, ignore instead of engage.  Frankly, I’m glad they pulled their Facebook Ads budget.  It was a waste of money.

I’m a Facebook lover…especially for marketing and generating leads for business. Automotive News ran an article this week saying (for 100th time) that Facebook is ineffective at selling cars. Really? They don’t have all the facts. They even quoted a guy from Honda who got his Facebook user stats wrong by 400+ million! Nice.

To those that read the article: please consider another opinion before you pass judgment.  There’s a lot of negative noise out there about Facebook Ads.  Most of it’s coming from those that are doing it wrong.  Calling out Facebook as the culprit in your failed advertising is like blaming the golf course for your lousy game.

Meanwhile, back in reality…Michael Scissons of AdAge writes that automotive will be a big Facebook Ad spending category if marketers can get it right.  The opportunity for Facebook Ads success is huge at the dealer level. Why? Successful dealership Social marketing is local because sales are local. How the dealers and their salespeople promote themselves and interact with their local community will become a competitive advantage to the companies who get it right. Private dealers and large auto groups alike should be spending money on locally-targeted Facebook advertising to drive local relationships, events and test drives.

Right now, the focus is upside down.  Dealers are making Facebook too complicated in one area and too simplistic in another.

They’re complicating things by bringing expectations based on the antiquated view of “Mad Men” era advertising.  Confusion sets in when the results they were looking for never materialize.  Give up trying to “get the word out”.  You can’t interrupt everyone just so you can talk about your stuff.   You used to be able to grab attention and turn it into money.  But now, attention is scarce.  People are interrupted by more interruptions.  We must earn attention and trust and turn that into money.

Dealers must cease this simplistic idea that anyone can “do” Facebook.  Successful advertising has ALWAYS required skill, experience and talent.  Facebook Ads call for that and much, much more.  Most businesses don’t set goals for Social Media or Facebook Ads.  A typical goal is “we just want people to buy our stuff”.  Hire a skilled expert to train your marketing manager.  Grow your own “in-house Social marketer” to write great content to engage people and increase your sales by designing, managing and monitoring Facebook Ads.

Display ads are over, folks.  They have morphed into something more relevant called Social Engagement Ads. In the Automotive News article, Ford had it right, “Our Facebook ads are effective when strategically combined with engaging content and innovation.”  Owned and earned media now have the fire power of paid advertising.  This is confusing for many who think in terms of display advertising.  Display used to be the dominant way to make sales because it stole attention.  Now, it’s a delicate balance between paid, owned and earned media.  It’s the savvy marketer who can unite all three and win.

Facebook and other Social Media platforms came along and replaced this idea of stealing attention.  Instead, Facebook gives you a platform with which to earn your customers’ attention.  You earn attention, build trust and turn it into profit.  It’s not easy but it does work when you do it right.

For dealers, successful Facebook Ads will help you meet your sales goals.  You laser-target to those that will most likely buy from you.  But coming to the table with the mindset of display ads and trying to apply it to socially-engaging Facebook Ads is useless. Embrace Social Engagement Ads and put them to work for your business.  “Get the word out” will take on a whole new meaning:  The good word spreads from person to person and that’s how sales happen.

  • http://www.justicewordlaw.com Justice Wordlaw IV

    Your blog post is correct in a lot of ways. I’ve primarily used Facebook ads to grow my business the past two years and have really loved the results that I’ve received from them. The companies such as these dealerships honestly don’t understand the method in which Facebook ads work. Their trying to use the same strategies that they would Google adwords and expect better results just because more people are using Facebook and that’s not the case whatsoever.

    If a car dealership can understand the psychology behind using Facebook ads and the various areas they should be focusing on they would never pull their budget of any size. You would understand that you can gain a targeted list of hungry buyers from incoming freshman of colleges to people that work for a specific company that you offer promotions to. If they were to track every thing they would have an endless amount of data that would be worth a lot more to them than they ever thought.

    But, they don’t think in that manner whatsoever. They typically say ” I want more Facebook likes”.

    Great post!

  • http://www.icon-presentations.com Jenise Fryatt

    Brilliant post, Kathi. I read somewhere that GM was spending that the $10 million in Facebook ads GM is discontinuing represents only 2 days of their ad spending. Imagine how many social media managers for local dealers this could pay for. What a colossal example of a marketing department unable to adapt to change.

  • http://www.krusecontrolinc.com Kathi Kruse

    Crazy isn’t it? For all the years I’ve spent running dealerships, the relationship between the factory and the dealer has been considered a partnership. Most of the OEMs I see now are doing nothing to support dealers in capitalizing on Social Media marketing…maybe because they haven’t taken the time to understand it themselves. I hope things change. Thanks so much for your insights, Jenise!

  • http://www.krusecontrolinc.com Kathi Kruse

    Cool, Justice. You are so right-on with them “wanting more Facebook likes”. It’s such a shame they’re missing out on these great opportunities. It sounds like you’ve really mastered Facebook Ads – I love hearing success stories. It’s all about what’s going right and capitalizing on that. Thanks so much for stopping by my blog!

  • http://toyota-talk.blogspot.com/ Erik Schwenke

    Excellent insight, Kathi. I’m not surprised GM pulled their ads when their content was so stale.
    Your comment about earning attention, rather than stealing it, is also spot on. Give your potential fans a reason to come to your page!

  • http://www.krusecontrolinc.com Kathi Kruse

    Thanks Erik!

Previous post:

Next post: