Managing used car inventory is a lot like trying to keep a refrigerator organized. Left to its own devices, it fills up with things that were once a good idea but are now questionable. A sound monthly policy – the dealership’s version of labeling leftovers – relies on data, discipline, and just enough urgency to keep things from rotting in the back.
The strange thing about cars on a lot is how human they can feel. A fresh arrival sparkles with possibility, full of promise and potential. By the 30-day mark, though, the shine begins to dull. The car hasn’t done anything wrong, really, it just hasn’t found its match. After sixty days, you’re not really seeing potential anymore; you’re calculating the cost of keeping it around. It’s the same realization you have when you notice that the clothes in your closet still have their tags on, reminding you with each glance that they were never the right fit.
This is where the discipline of inventory management steps in. Done right, it creates order, consistency, and cash flow. Done poorly, it leaves a lot full of stale units, drained PVR, and managers wondering why nothing seems to move.
Turning a Tough Job Into a Workable System
I’ve worn a few hats in dealerships – CFO, COO, executive manager – and along the way I’ve crossed paths with more Used Car Managers than I can count. It’s a tough role, often thankless, and sometimes downright exhausting. Whether seasoned veterans or fresh faces, they all share one thing in common: the need for a reliable system to keep inventory under control. What follows isn’t theory or wishful thinking. It’s a proven policy that, when applied with discipline, actually works.
Step One: Start With the Data
Any good monthly policy begins with an honest look at what’s been happening. You don’t need to hire a fortune teller; just look at your sales over the past 30 to 90 days. Which models sold quickly? Which ones sat so long you could have used them to measure the passing of seasons?
The goal here is to match your stocking strategy to reality, not wishful thinking. Maybe sedans are selling well in your market while trucks lag behind, or perhaps your area is flooded with compact SUVs and you’re better off focusing on something less common. By reviewing both your own history and local demand, you can decide which vehicles to keep, which to move quickly, and which to politely show the door via the auction.
The beauty of this step is its practicality. It’s a reminder that dealership management isn’t about gut feelings or nostalgia for what used to sell. It’s about adapting inventory to what customers actually want today.
Step Two: Draw the Line in the Sand
Once you know what’s moving, it’s time to set benchmarks. These are the guardrails that keep everyone on track. Top-performing dealerships often aim to retail at least 50-55% of their inventory within 30 days. In competitive markets, some push that target to 80%.
These numbers aren’t arbitrary; they’re survival tools. After the thirty-day mark, gross profit begins to erode. By 60 days, you’re often looking at a unit that’s costing you money instead of making it.
To make it manageable, many dealerships categorize inventory by age: 0 to 10 days, 11 to 20, 21 to 30, and so on. This creates a simple system where managers can quickly see which cars are on track and which ones are approaching the danger zone. Think of it like the expiration dates on milk cartons: you wouldn’t keep a gallon of milk for 90 days and expect it to be fine. Cars are no different.
Step Three: Daily and Weekly Check-Ins
This is where discipline becomes routine. Every week, managers walk the lot, look at cars online, and note what isn’t moving. Sometimes the problem is obvious: a vehicle is priced too high, its photos look like they were taken with a flip phone, or it hasn’t been properly detailed. Other times, it’s harder to spot. Maybe it’s just not attracting interest.
These lot walks aren’t glamorous, but they are invaluable. They force you to look each unit in the eye and ask, “Why are you still here?” It’s a little like checking in on houseplants: you can tell quickly who’s thriving and who’s quietly wilting in the corner. The goal isn’t to assign blame but to solve problems quickly, before they grow more expensive.
Step Four: Price With the Clock, Not Your Heart
It’s tempting to believe that every vehicle just needs the right buyer, but aging targets require a more practical approach.
Cars don’t age like wine; they age like bananas.
The longer vehicles sit, the less appealing they become, and the faster they need to be priced to move.
Incremental price adjustments are the key. Instead of one dramatic drop, prices shift downward in stages as a vehicle ages. This approach maintains urgency without panicking customers. It also signals transparency: buyers can see the dealership is serious about moving inventory, which builds trust and often speeds up the sale.
Think of pricing as setting a timer. Each adjustment acknowledges that time is passing, and with it, the profit margin. Better to act early than to wait until you’re practically giving the car away and taking a huge writedown.
Step Five: Monitor the Rhythm
Each month, it’s important to step back and review the big picture. The most common metric here is the turnover ratio. A strong target is 12 times annually, which means each vehicle sells roughly once per month.
This isn’t just a vanity number. A healthy turnover ratio signals that your processes are working, your benchmarks are being enforced, and your lot is more showroom than storage unit.
Alongside turnover, managers also review yesterday’s appraisals to check for accuracy. Were the valuations realistic? Did the market move in an unexpected direction? These check-ins keep everyone honest.
It’s not unlike rereading an old email and realizing you may have overstated your case. Humbling, yes, but ultimately corrective.
Step Six: Spotlight the Slackers
No policy is complete without dealing with the stragglers. Units that reach 60 days or more can’t be allowed to fade into the background. They need attention, marketing, and urgency.
This often means moving them to the front line, creating special promotions, or targeting advertising directly at buyers who’ve shown interest in similar vehicles. Sometimes it means deeper discounts. Other times, the most sensible choice is auction or wholesale disposal.
The point is not to punish the car but to protect the dealership. Every aging unit is like a leak in the roof: small at first, but increasingly damaging the longer it’s ignored.
Step Seven: Document and Communicate
Policies don’t work without accountability. Every two weeks, managers should receive reports showing the age and performance of inventory. These reports aren’t meant to decorate inboxes, they demand action.
Managers are expected to review, respond, and adjust. Maybe that means scheduling a price change, approving a marketing campaign, or finally admitting a car has to go to auction. The consistency of reporting keeps the process alive and ensures nothing slips through the cracks.
Why This Matters
It’s easy to dismiss all of this as administrative busywork, but the consequences of ignoring aging targets are severe. Each day a vehicle sits unsold, it loses profit potential. After thirty days, the decline accelerates. By sixty days, gross profit can disappear altogether.
Enforcing targets creates urgency and discipline. It keeps inventory fresh, improves cash flow, and builds customer trust by showing that pricing is responsive and transparent. More importantly, it creates a rhythm for the dealership. Instead of lurching from one problem to the next, managers follow a clear process that prevents stagnation.
The beauty of this approach isn’t in the numbers alone. It’s in the order it brings. Like good dental hygiene, it’s rarely exciting, but it saves you from far more painful problems down the road.
The Summary Flow
For those who prefer bullet points to prose, here’s the flow:
- Analyze and stock inventory based on recent sales data.
- Set and enforce aging targets.
- Price vehicles dynamically based on age and market.
- Review appraisals daily and inventory weekly.
- Aggressively market or dispose of aging stock.
- Report and act on results every two weeks.
This isn’t just theory. Dealers that adopt and stick to this process consistently report better profitability, higher turn rates, and more satisfied customers. Like any good ritual, it works because it’s repeated.
And so, month after month, the process begins again. A fresh set of cars arrives, full of potential. Managers analyze, categorize, and act. Some cars sell quickly, others linger, but none are forgotten. It’s not glamorous, but it is reliable. And in the unpredictable world of used car retail, reliability is its own kind of magic.
Get Automotive CFO-level insights without the full-time cost. We identify inefficiencies, fix cash flow issues, and unlock opportunities, all at no net cost to your dealership.